The Best Toy Mice For Cats To Tap Into Their Inner Predator

The Best Toy Mice For Cats To Tap Into Their Inner Predator

Mice are a cat's natural prey, but thankfully, you can skip the bloodshed of catching real mice and opt for the best toy mice to keep your feline occupied and sharpen their predatory instincts.

By Molly Wolfe March 31, 2023

If you’ve got a cat at home, chances are you’re thinking about what the best toys are to keep them healthy, active, and entertained. Enter: toy mice. Mice tap into cats’ natural instincts, and are exactly the kind of small mammal they’re likely to hunt in the wild. Chasing and catching helps to fine-tune your cat’s hunting instincts, which they still need—despite having dinner prepared and served to them by yours truly.

It’s important to keep your cat’s instincts sharp, and mice toys are one of the best ways to do that. Not to mention, playing with your cat helps to forge a solid bond and is super fun for both you and your feline! And of course, with mice toys costing very little, you won’t burn a hole in your pocket, either. So, pick up the best toy mice for cats from our ultimate guide, and you can watch your cat go all Itchy and Scratchy for hours on end.

awardImageUrl

Top Pick SPOT Ethical Pets Frankie Mouse Toy for Cats

SPOT Ethical Pets 52083 Flat Mouse Frankie Catnip Toys, All Breed Sizes

Best Toy Mice for Cats to Consider

Materials

It’s important you choose safe, non-toxic materials for your cat toys. After all, they’re almost certainly going to be biting, chewing, and licking their new toy (especially if you spray it with a dab of catnip!). So, natural materials are always your best bet, from wood to cork on the harder side to hemp and wool on the softer front. While cheap and cheerful cat toys might be made from less healthy materials, you won’t be doing your kitty any favors as they could be exposed to harmful chemicals or even choke hazards.

Choking Hazards

Be wary of toy mice with add-ons like bells or bows, since these extra bits have a habit of coming off. Just like with young children, any small, detachable pieces present a choking risk, which we’re sure you don’t want for your beloved kitty. So, look for toys without add-ons or toys with very secure stitching to keep your cats safe during play.

Benefits of Mice Toys for Cats

While there are plenty of toy types to go for when it comes to updating your cat’s toy box, mice toys are the go-to classic. Why? Because mice are a cat’s natural prey, and they’ll be able to tap into their predatorial instincts to chase, stalk, and pounce on that furry little mouse. While we advise against bringing real mice into the equation (cruel and unnecessary), the best toy mice for cats provide a happy alternative that’ll hone your cat’s hunting skills while keeping the bloodshed at bay.

SPOT Ethical Pets Frankie Mouse Toy for Cats

Impressively realistic and made with the all-important dab of catnip to encourage play, this toy mouse for cats is an excellent addition to their indoor toy collection. The versatile design means there’s ample scope for different types of play; throw it around the room and watch your kitty dive after it, use the tail to make a chase game, or simply leave it somewhere for your cat to use as as they see fit.  Soft, well-made, and coming in at a great price, this mouse toy is a winner for us.

Top Pick
SPOT Ethical Pets 52083 Flat Mouse Frankie Catnip Toys, All Breed Sizes

SPOT Ethical Pets 52083 Flat Mouse Frankie Catnip Toys, All Breed Sizes

$5.79

Buy on Amazon

Pros:

  • Beautifully rustic design
  • Soft and ergonomic
  • Lots of scope for different games
  • Good price tag

Cons:

  • Tail could be longer to make a good chaser toy

Fur Mice Toys for Cats

Packed with 12 little mice for your cat to hunt, tease, and pounce on, this set of mice toys is worth your bucks. Not only are they soft and oh-so-tempting for your cats, but they also make a gentle rattling sound your cats will love. Your cats will love playing with these mice toys, and they’ll certainly be distracting from scratching your furniture, which is great news for you.

We like that the mice are made to resemble the real deal, measuring up at a lifelike size. So, you’ll be hoodwinking your kitties into thinking a real-life mouse family has moved in. Packed with black, grey, and white mice, there’s plenty of variety, too.

Runner Up
Penn-Plax Play Fur Mice Cat Toys | Mixed Bag of 12 Play Mice with Rattling Sounds | 3 Color Variety Pack - CAT531, Black and White

Penn-Plax Play Fur Mice Cat Toys | Mixed Bag of 12 Play Mice with Rattling Sounds | 3 Color Variety Pack - CAT531, Black and White

$9.99

Buy on Amazon

Pros:

  • 12 mice in every pack
  • 3 colors
  • Soft and safe
  • Rattling sounds

Cons:

  • Not the most sophisticated toy, but cats love them

OurPets Play-N-Squeak Twice the Mice Cat Toys

We’d forgive you for thinking these toy mice were the real thing; just look at that realistic craftsmanship! We’re pretty sure your cats will be easily convinced, too. Boasting added catnip to enhance your cat’s interest plus a realistic squeaking mouse sound, these mice toys will have your felines hightailing over for a pounce and play.

Add these mice to your cat’s toy collection and encourage healthy play, nurture their hunting instincts, and relieve boredom—which is especially important for keeping indoor cats active, particularly if you’re at work all day.

Most Realistic
OurPets Play-N-Squeak Twice the Mice Cat Toy, 2pc (Interactive Cat Toy, Catnip Toy, Catnip Toys for Cats, Real Mouse Electronic Sound, Catnip, Cat Toys)

OurPets Play-N-Squeak Twice the Mice Cat Toy, 2pc (Interactive Cat Toy, Catnip Toy, Catnip Toys for Cats, Real Mouse Electronic Sound, Catnip, Cat Toys)

$13.73

Buy on Amazon

Pros:

  • Super realistic aesthetic
  • Electronic mouse sound
  • Made with catnip scent
  • Great value

Cons:

  • Mouse sound is rather loud

CHIWAVA Mice Toys for Cats

Boasting a whopping 36 little mice toys in every pack, you’ll have enough to keep your cats occupied for years to come. Tiny, cute, and colorful, these mice toys make lovely, engaging entertainment for your felines. Complete with catnip and a rattling sound, these multi-sensory cat toys will captivate your kitty’s senses and have them raring to go. You can join in the fun with these enrichment toys, or simply leave them out and about in your home for your cats to create their own hunting games.

Top Pick
CHIWAVA 36 Pack 1.8 Inch Small Interactive Cat Toys Mice with Catnip Rattle Sound Mouse for Indoor Cats Kitten Play

CHIWAVA 36 Pack 1.8 Inch Small Interactive Cat Toys Mice with Catnip Rattle Sound Mouse for Indoor Cats Kitten Play

$11.98

Buy on Amazon

Pros:

  • 36 tiny mice per pack
  • Cute bright colors
  • Made with catnip
  • Rattle sound to engage the senses

Cons:

  • On the smaller side

Kissmi Furry Mice Toys for Cats

These furry little beauties are on hand to keep your kitty entertained come day or night. Coming in a pack of 20, these mice toys for cats will tease out your feline’s natural hunting instincts, letting them run riot with their new prey until the cows come home. We love the assortment of rainbow colors, adding an extra element of fun to these mice toys. There’s a gentle rattling sound to captivate your cats even more, too. Don’t worry, it’s not too loud; you’ll still be able to get a good sleep even while your cat is getting some early-hours playtime in.

Also Consider
Kissmi 20 Pack Furry Cat Toys Mice Rattle Mice Cat Catcher Assorted Color

Kissmi 20 Pack Furry Cat Toys Mice Rattle Mice Cat Catcher Assorted Color

$10.99

Buy on Amazon

Pros:

  • 20 toys per pack
  • Bright colors
  • Rattling sound
  • Great size for chasing and batting
  • Cheap price tag

Cons:

  • Eyes and noses can be a little loose

Frequently Asked Questions

Are mouse toys good for cats?

All cat toys, including mouse toys ,are a great way to engage your cat in physical activity; this is especially important if they’re indoor cats who don’t have so much nature to run about in. Your cat will naturally gravitate towards their new mouse toy since it’ll play into their natural instincts and encourage them to scout, pounce, and catch. Adding mouse toys into the equation will also build your bond with them, sharpen their motor skills, and fine-tune their instincts. So, all in all, mouse toys are great for cats.

Is it safe for cats to eat mice?

It’s not ideal for your cat to chow down on a mouse, no. However, it’s very rare that it’ll cause them actual harm. Mice are known to carry parasites and bacteria that can cause your kitty to experience nausea and other negative symptoms if ingested,

Do cats play with mice?

True to their reputation, cats do indeed love to play with mice. If a mouse enters your house and your cat spots it, it’ll likely hunt, chase, and pounce on the litter creature.

Are female cats better mousers?

Female cats tend to be better at catching mice than their male counterparts. This is partly because in the wild, female cats would’ve had to hunt for not just themselves, but also for their litters, which meant they became highly skilled hunters with an eye for catching prey and the sharp instincts to match.

WHY TRUST US

Since 2008, Cattime has served as a leading resource for millions of cat owners and pet lovers alike. Our goal is to give every cat and pet a happy, healthy home by providing owners with all information they need to be the best pet parents possible. Our experts share their insights and recommendations to make caring for your beloved pet a breeze.

See The Latest Articles From Cattime Editors

The Best Indoor Cat Gates For Rowdy Kittens
The Best Indoor Cat Gates For Rowdy Kittens

We all know cats love to roam their home as if they own it. However, sometimes they don’t know what’s best for them, and we, the blessed cat owners, need to step in with some tough love. One way to keep them in their room is to use an indoor cat gate. These are designed to keep pets from entering certain areas of the house. While you’re here, you can check out the best cat doors to give your kitty more space to roam outside, and the best cat jungle gyms to give them something to do inside on a rainy day. To help you find the right one for you and your cat, we’ve done some research. In our search, we found the top indoor cat gates in a variety of shapes, sizes, and colors. Keep on reading if you’d like to learn more about them.

The 5 Best Cat Doors To Give Your Kitties More Freedom And Independence
The 5 Best Cat Doors To Give Your Kitties More Freedom And Independence

Cats love to roam the great outdoors. However, it can be a nuisance to constantly let them in and out of the house all day. The solution is to install a cat door so they can exit and enter as they please. With a good cat door, they’re free to roam inside and out, pop in for some tasty cat food or settle down for a nap in their luxe cat bed. These are relatively easy to set up, but you will have to cut into a wall or door, so you might want to hire a professional. Besides that, most doors are incredibly easy to install and simple to use. We’ve done the research and have found the top cat doors on the market. Give your kitty the freedom it craves with one of these excellent doors. Read on below to learn more.

The Best Cat Collars With Bells So You Can Hear Them Coming
The Best Cat Collars With Bells So You Can Hear Them Coming

Though a seemingly simple concept, cat bell collars actually offer a huge amount of benefits for you and your local wildlife. How? Well, by wearing a tinkling bell collar, birds, mice, and other potential prey will be alerted to the presence of your cat before they’ve had a chance to strike. In turn, this prevents your cat from ingesting any bacteria from any real-life hunted prey. So, it’s truly a win-win for everyone! After all, they can flex their hunting instincts with some fun cat toys, without the bloodshed. Not to mention, you’ll be able to hear your cat even if you can’t see them, which is great for those of us with a penchant for worrying. Oh, and of course, the collars look super cute, so there’s that. So, if you’ve got a new kitten or your adult cat simply needs some new neckwear, check out our guide to the best cat collars with bells so you can give them a chic style update and save your local wildlife in the process.

The Best Heated Cat Beds To Keep Your Feline Cozy On A Cold Day
The Best Heated Cat Beds To Keep Your Feline Cozy On A Cold Day

Cats love comfort—in fact, they’re renowned for it. And of course, a species that can sleep up to 16 hours in a single day needs a warm, cozy spot to slumber. Enter: heated cat beds. The feline equivalent of a heated blanket, the best heated cat beds will give your kitty-cat a toasty place to perch when the weather takes a turn. Naturally, it lends itself to the winter months, but you can use your heated cat bed any time of year to ensure your cat has somewhere warm to nap. These days, the cat beds tend to be energy-efficient, so you shouldn’t have to worry about your bills going through the roof. Plus, there’s usually an adjustable thermostat, so you can tailor the temperature just as your cat likes it. Alternatively, you can opt for a self-warming cat bed to skip the electricity element altogether. Depending on the brand, you may be able to remove the heater entirely and repurpose it as a regular cat bed, which is great for the warmer months. Converted? We thought so. We’ve put together the ultimate guide to our favorite heated cat beds to help you shop. Read on and check them out now.

The Best Real Wood Cat Trees For Scratching, Play, And Relaxation
The Best Real Wood Cat Trees For Scratching, Play, And Relaxation

When it comes to choosing the best cat tree, real wood is a solid option—in all senses. Wood is sturdy, reliable, and long-lasting, and of course, these are all characteristics you want from your new cat tree. Spending a little more to find the best quality wood makes a world of difference, ensuring you won’t find yourself splashing out for a new cat tree sooner than you expected. It’ll withstand your cats’ rough-and-tumble play, jumping, and scratches; not to mention, a real wood cat tree offers heaps of chic style to your space, showing your guests you only pick the best. So, if you’re replacing your old cat tree or jungle gym, or buying one for the first time, we’ve got you covered with the best real wood cat trees here. Read on and check them out—we’ve got options for all styles and budgets.

The Best Toy Mice For Cats To Tap Into Their Inner Predator
The Best Toy Mice For Cats To Tap Into Their Inner Predator

If you’ve got a cat at home, chances are you’re thinking about what the best toys are to keep them healthy, active, and entertained. Enter: toy mice. Mice tap into cats’ natural instincts, and are exactly the kind of small mammal they’re likely to hunt in the wild. Chasing and catching helps to fine-tune your cat’s hunting instincts, which they still need—despite having dinner prepared and served to them by yours truly. It’s important to keep your cat’s instincts sharp, and mice toys are one of the best ways to do that. Not to mention, playing with your cat helps to forge a solid bond and is super fun for both you and your feline! And of course, with mice toys costing very little, you won’t burn a hole in your pocket, either. So, pick up the best toy mice for cats from our ultimate guide, and you can watch your cat go all Itchy and Scratchy for hours on end.

The 5 Best Cat Litter Box Liners For Easy Maintenance
The 5 Best Cat Litter Box Liners For Easy Maintenance

Cats may be known for their cleanliness, but the dreaded chore of scooping out clumps of litter is enough to make any cat owner want to throw in the towel (or, in this case, the litter scoop). But fear not, feline friends. There exists a magical invention that can make your life easier and your kitty’s bathroom experience more comfortable: litter box liners. Yes, you read that right — there are liners specifically designed to fit into your kitty’s trusty little potty. Think of it as a fitted sheet for your cat’s bed, but instead of bedding, it lines their poop palace with an extra layer of protection. Not only does this help keep things tidy for you (no more scraping dried-up pee), but it also makes changing out old litter a breeze. But before you go running off to buy any ol’ liner, beware. Not all liners are created equal. Some may rip easily or cause unwanted odor buildup. That’s why we’ve done our research and rounded up the best options on the market so you can spend less time worrying about scooping and more time playing with your furry friend. So come join us as we explore this world of cat litter box liners – because anything that makes this chore even slightly more pleasant is worth investigating.

The 5 Best Cat Calming Treats To Ease Anxious Cats
The 5 Best Cat Calming Treats To Ease Anxious Cats

Cats are known for their independent and often unpredictable nature. While they may seem calm and collected one minute, their behavior can quickly change if something triggers anxiety or stress. Unfortunately, feline anxiety is a common problem that many cat owners struggle to manage. If you’re looking for a way to combat this, try out a cat calming treat. These delicious delights are specially formulated with natural ingredients like chamomile, valerian root, and L-tryptophan, designed to calm your cat and reduce feelings of unease. Not only do these cat treats help to alleviate anxiety-related issues like destructive behavior or excessive meowing, but they may also promote better sleep quality by inducing feelings of serenity and tranquility. Whether you’re dealing with separation anxiety, fear of loud noises or unfamiliar environments, or just general nervousness, the best calming cat treats offer an effective way to soothe your kitty without resorting to harsh medications. With no known harmful side effects or risks commonly associated with prescription medication use in pets, these treats make it easier than ever before to keep your feline companion happy and relaxed. Keep reading to learn more.

The Best Cat Toys To Keep Your Kitty's Mind Sharp And Their Body Active
The Best Cat Toys To Keep Your Kitty's Mind Sharp And Their Body Active

There’s a treasure chest of cat toys on the market for you to snap up for your kitty-cat. Play is super important in any cat’s life, especially if they spend much of their time indoors. From classic mouse toys to catnip toys to wands, feather and ball toys, you can create quite a toy box for your feline to delve into whenever they’re feeling playful. Not only are toys super fun, but they also help you bond with your cat, sharpen their motor skills, and tap into their natural hunting instincts. So, whether you’ve got a brand new kitten or a wise, elderly cat, they’ll all benefit from having a few of the best toys for cats kicking about at home to pass those hours between breakfast and dinner. Read on for our ultimate guide; we’ve got great options to suit all budgets.

The Best Toy Mice For Cats To Tap Into Their Inner Predator
The Best Toy Mice For Cats To Tap Into Their Inner Predator

If you’ve got a cat at home, chances are you’re thinking about what the best toys are to keep them healthy, active, and entertained. Enter: toy mice. Mice tap into cats’ natural instincts, and are exactly the kind of small mammal they’re likely to hunt in the wild. Chasing and catching helps to fine-tune your cat’s hunting instincts, which they still need—despite having dinner prepared and served to them by yours truly. It’s important to keep your cat’s instincts sharp, and mice toys are one of the best ways to do that. Not to mention, playing with your cat helps to forge a solid bond and is super fun for both you and your feline! And of course, with mice toys costing very little, you won’t burn a hole in your pocket, either. So, pick up the best toy mice for cats from our ultimate guide, and you can watch your cat go all Itchy and Scratchy for hours on end.

The Best Indoor Cat Gates For Rowdy Kittens
The Best Indoor Cat Gates For Rowdy Kittens

We all know cats love to roam their home as if they own it. However, sometimes they don’t know what’s best for them, and we, the blessed cat owners, need to step in with some tough love. One way to keep them in their room is to use an indoor cat gate. These are designed to keep pets from entering certain areas of the house. While you’re here, you can check out the best cat doors to give your kitty more space to roam outside, and the best cat jungle gyms to give them something to do inside on a rainy day. To help you find the right one for you and your cat, we’ve done some research. In our search, we found the top indoor cat gates in a variety of shapes, sizes, and colors. Keep on reading if you’d like to learn more about them.

The 5 Best Cat Doors To Give Your Kitties More Freedom And Independence
The 5 Best Cat Doors To Give Your Kitties More Freedom And Independence

Cats love to roam the great outdoors. However, it can be a nuisance to constantly let them in and out of the house all day. The solution is to install a cat door so they can exit and enter as they please. With a good cat door, they’re free to roam inside and out, pop in for some tasty cat food or settle down for a nap in their luxe cat bed. These are relatively easy to set up, but you will have to cut into a wall or door, so you might want to hire a professional. Besides that, most doors are incredibly easy to install and simple to use. We’ve done the research and have found the top cat doors on the market. Give your kitty the freedom it craves with one of these excellent doors. Read on below to learn more.

The Best Cat Collars With Bells So You Can Hear Them Coming
The Best Cat Collars With Bells So You Can Hear Them Coming

Though a seemingly simple concept, cat bell collars actually offer a huge amount of benefits for you and your local wildlife. How? Well, by wearing a tinkling bell collar, birds, mice, and other potential prey will be alerted to the presence of your cat before they’ve had a chance to strike. In turn, this prevents your cat from ingesting any bacteria from any real-life hunted prey. So, it’s truly a win-win for everyone! After all, they can flex their hunting instincts with some fun cat toys, without the bloodshed. Not to mention, you’ll be able to hear your cat even if you can’t see them, which is great for those of us with a penchant for worrying. Oh, and of course, the collars look super cute, so there’s that. So, if you’ve got a new kitten or your adult cat simply needs some new neckwear, check out our guide to the best cat collars with bells so you can give them a chic style update and save your local wildlife in the process.

The Best Heated Cat Beds To Keep Your Feline Cozy On A Cold Day
The Best Heated Cat Beds To Keep Your Feline Cozy On A Cold Day

Cats love comfort—in fact, they’re renowned for it. And of course, a species that can sleep up to 16 hours in a single day needs a warm, cozy spot to slumber. Enter: heated cat beds. The feline equivalent of a heated blanket, the best heated cat beds will give your kitty-cat a toasty place to perch when the weather takes a turn. Naturally, it lends itself to the winter months, but you can use your heated cat bed any time of year to ensure your cat has somewhere warm to nap. These days, the cat beds tend to be energy-efficient, so you shouldn’t have to worry about your bills going through the roof. Plus, there’s usually an adjustable thermostat, so you can tailor the temperature just as your cat likes it. Alternatively, you can opt for a self-warming cat bed to skip the electricity element altogether. Depending on the brand, you may be able to remove the heater entirely and repurpose it as a regular cat bed, which is great for the warmer months. Converted? We thought so. We’ve put together the ultimate guide to our favorite heated cat beds to help you shop. Read on and check them out now.

The Best Real Wood Cat Trees For Scratching, Play, And Relaxation
The Best Real Wood Cat Trees For Scratching, Play, And Relaxation

When it comes to choosing the best cat tree, real wood is a solid option—in all senses. Wood is sturdy, reliable, and long-lasting, and of course, these are all characteristics you want from your new cat tree. Spending a little more to find the best quality wood makes a world of difference, ensuring you won’t find yourself splashing out for a new cat tree sooner than you expected. It’ll withstand your cats’ rough-and-tumble play, jumping, and scratches; not to mention, a real wood cat tree offers heaps of chic style to your space, showing your guests you only pick the best. So, if you’re replacing your old cat tree or jungle gym, or buying one for the first time, we’ve got you covered with the best real wood cat trees here. Read on and check them out—we’ve got options for all styles and budgets.

HAPPY PAWS FROM CATTIME

Top Searches On Cattime